Kathmandu School of Law Review

P-ISSN : 2091-2110, E-ISSN : 2773-8159, DOI : 10.46985, Publisher : Kathmandu School of Law, Nepal
Annual flagship journal of Kathmandu School of Law, Nepal

Volume 7, Issue 1, April 2019
Articles

Right to Freedom of Religion and Right to Clean Environment: A case of Bagmati River, Pashupatinath Temple

PDF
  • Dia Maijadh Yonzon
    ,
  • Ojaswi K. C.
Dia Maijadh Yonzon
Feminist and a Writer, Open Institute for Social Science, Gender Research
Ojaswi K. C.
legal researcher, Master’s Degree, Human Rights and Democratisation, Mahidol University
DOI: https://doi.org/10.46985/kslr.v7i1.1205

Published 2021-03-05

How to Cite

Yonzon, D. M., & K. C., O. . (2021). Right to Freedom of Religion and Right to Clean Environment: A case of Bagmati River, Pashupatinath Temple. Kathmandu School of Law Review, 7(1), 112–129. https://doi.org/10.46985/kslr.v7i1.1205
Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

This research deals with two fundamental rights listed in the Constitution of Nepal, 2015; the Right to freedom of religion and the Right to clean environment with a special reference to the Bagmati River and riverbank in Pashupatinath Temple. The aim of the research is to visualize a clean river while keeping in mind the continuation of centuriesold traditions. The research explores the question of whether the religious practices performed in the river are destructible to the river ecosystem or not. It further tries to see the stance of state regarding its approach to finding the middle ground between the two different fundamental rights. The researchers have assessed this dimension through the study of ritual performance in the banks of Bagmati River, state policy and citizen’s attitude regarding this issue. Bagmati River is considered as a holiest of holy by followers of Hinduism. It provides a sample to understand the significant role played by other Hindu temples and their river banks located in the territory of Nepal in determining the river’ s purposes along with the sustainability of the river and its tributaries.

PDF

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

  1. The River Valley Civilization Guide available at http://www.rivervalleycivilizations.com/, accessed on 16 April 2018.
  2. That booming laughter rolled out of his mouth took the forms of an unsullied river, swirling with sacred water, and whitened by foamy waves. See Lucia De Vires, ‘Walking the holy river’, Nepali Times (29 Jan 4 Feb 2016 #793) available at http://archive.nepalitimes.com/article/Nepali-Times-Buzz/need-topreserve the-spiritual-heritage-of-the-Bagmati-river, 2844, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  3. Oskar Frelin & Jens Hansen Holm, ‘Healing Bagmati’, Masters of Landscape Architecture thesis, University of Copenhagen, 2016 available at http://www.healingbagmati.com/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  4. Kathmandu Valley Environment Outlook, International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) Ministry of Environment, Science and Technology (MoEST) and United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), January 2007 available at http://lib.icimod.org/record/7434/files/KVEO-Full-text.pdf.,accessed on 30 September 2018.
  5. Oskar Frelin, ‘Resurrecting the river’, Nepali Times (2-8 March 2018) available at http://archive.nepalitimes.com/page/resurrecting-bagmati-the-river, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  6. The ghats (cremation platforms) are located at the banks of Bagmati River in Pashupatinath temple. It is listed in the World Heritage site (WHS) and is divided into Arya Ghat and Bhansmeshwor Ghat. See Frelin and Holm. According to the legend, ghats are also known as stairs. It used to refer to the meaning of stairway to heaven or the path of salvation. The descending steps of ghats are interrupted at regular intervals with specially raised circular or cylindrical stone platforms known as Bhakari. The Bhakaris are square in shape and are used for cremation. See Prabhat Shrestha, Deputy Project Director of Bagmati River Basin Improvement project, A Brief on Ghats and Bhakaris along Bagmati River, Bagmati, published by High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of the Bagmati Civilization, Chaitra 2074.
  7. Bagmati Action Plan (2009-2014), published by High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of the Bagmati Civilization and National Trust for Nature Conservation available at http://www.bagmati.gov.np/uploaded/Bagmati-Action-Plan-En.pdf, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  8. Sudip Phyual, Bagmati Cleaning Campaign- No ultimate Victory, published by High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of the Bagmati Civilization, Chaitra 2074.
  9. Frelin & Hansen (n 3).
  10. The Pashupatinath Temple is considered as one of the sacred Hindu temples. It is located on the banks of the Bagmati River in the Kathmandu Valley, the capital city of Nepal. The temple is considered as a home of Hindu deity, Lord Pashupatinath. This temple complex was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage Sites’ list in 1979.
  11. O Frelin & Hansen (n 3).
  12. There are certain rituals which involve offerings to the river, for example, Hindu followers offers Pinda, Arpan,andTarpan to the memories of their deceased loved ones, believing that deceased will obtain those offerings through the Bagmati River which has a holy status. This rite is known as a Shrada in Hindu culture.
  13. Katrina Keane, ‘Suitably Modern’ available at http://katrinakeane.com/abstract/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  14. Each step symbolizes the next part of a religious practice which has had been passed down from generation to generation. One side of the river focuses on the transition into the next life, which includes blessings, the burning, and parting of the physical body. The stairs of the other side of the river is reserved for rituals of blessing, offerings, and the absolution of sins in the current life. See Katrina Keane, ‘Suitably Modern’ available at http://katrinakeane.com/abstract/, accessed on 30th September 2018.
  15. Keshab Poudel, ‘Where the River Flows’, ECS Nepal, July 10, 2010 available at http://ecs.com.np/features/where-the-rivers-flow, accessed on 16 April 2018.
  16. UNESCO, World Heritage Site List available at http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/121, accessed on 16 April 2018.
  17. Jerry A. Nathanson, ‘Environmental Pollution’, Encyclopedia Britannica available at https://www.britannica.
  18. com/science/pollution-environment, assessed on 30 September 2018.
  19. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 999 UNTS 171, adopted on 16 December 1966 AD, art. 18.
  20. International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 993 UNTS 3, adopted on 16 December 1966 AD, art. 12(b).
  21. Rajendra Pradhan, 'Law, History and Culture of Water in Nepal' available at; http://soscbaha.org/lectureseries xliv-2/, accessed on 25 September 2018.
  22. The word culture is used in various settings to convey different meanings. But commonly it is regarded as an acquired knowledge from one’s society.
  23. Amos Rapoport born on 28 March 1929 in Warsaw is an architect and one of the founders of Environment Behavior Studies (EBS). He is the author of over 200 academic publications in this field. His work has focused mainly on the role of cultural variables, cross-cultural studies, and theory development and synthesis.
  24. Amos Rapoport, History and Precedent in Environment Design, Plenum Press, New York and London, 1990.
  25. Roger S. Gottlieb, The Sacred Earth; Religion, Nature, and Environment, Routledge, New York and London, 2006, p. 2.
  26. Joanna Macy, World as Lover, World as Self, Parallax Press, Berkeley, California, 1991, pp. 16–17.
  27. Rob Bailey, Antony Froggatt & Laura Wellesley, Livestock - Climate Change’s Forgotten Sector: Global Public Opinion on Meat and Dairy Consumption, Chatham House, The Royal Institute of
  28. International Affairs, 2014 available at https://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/default/files/field/field_ document/20141203LivestockClimateChangeForgottenSectorBaileyFroggattWellesleyFinal.pdf, accessed on 25 September 2018.
  29. Anne M. Rademacher, ‘Restoration, and Revival: Remembering the Bagmati Civilization’ in Arjun Guneratne (ed), Culture and the Environment in the Himalaya, Routledge, London and New York, 2010.
  30. ‘Environmental Ethics’, first published 03 June 2002, substantive revision 21 July 2015, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy available at https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ethics-environmental/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  31. Jack Donnelly, Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice, Cornell University Press, 2013, p. 30.
  32. Bagmati River Basin Improvement Project (BRBIP) available at http://www.brbip.gov.np/index.php, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  33. Ibid.
  34. Nivesh Dugar is an Environmental Engineer based in Nepal. He is a freelance researcher working in the field of water quality and solid waste management.
  35. Asana Shakya is an Environmental scientist based in Nepal whose field of interest is in water quality and soil waste.
  36. The respondents were from the age group 16-25(119 respondents), 23-35(24 respondents), 36-45 (2 respondents), 46-55 (1 respondent), and one respondent did not identify the age.
  37. Deaths, and especially cremation, are symbolically constructed as a sacrificial offering of the self to the gods. See, Jonathan P. Parry, Death in Banaras, Lewis Henry Morgan Lectures, Cambridge University Press, 1994, chp. 5.
  38. Originally from Kaveri District of Nepal, Rudra Prasad Parajuli has been working as a Pundit in the Pashupatinath Temple for 25 years.
  39. Originally from Ramechhap District of Nepal, Rudra Bhandari has been working as a Pundit in the Pashupatinath Temple for 15 years.
  40. If the mortuary rites are neglected or inadequately performed, the cycle is disrupted, and the result is barrenness, miscarriages, the death of infants and a decline in the family fortunes. See, Jonathan P. Parry, Death in Banaras, Lewis Henry Morgan Lectures, Cambridge University Press, 1994, chp 7.
  41. Shanti Khadka is a devotee of Lord Pashupatinath. She visits the Temple more than four or five times a week.
  42. Shambhu Paudel works in register desk at Pashupati Electric Crematorium, Ring Road, Kathmandu 44600.
  43. Kumar Thapa Magar works as Administration Officer at Pashupati Electric Crematorium, Ring Road, Kathmandu 44600.
  44. Annual Bodies Burned in Pashupati Electronic Pyre: 2072/10/10 – 2073 /03/30: 1853, 2073/04/01 – 2074/03/30: 3715, 2074/04/01 - 2075/03/30: 2267
  45. ‘Cremation Waste and Toxins’, Metals in Medicine and the Environment available at http://faculty.virginia.edu/ metals/cases/huffman1.htm, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  46. Shambhu Paudel works in register desk at Pashupati Electric Crematorium, Ring Road, Kathmandu 44600.
  47. Bodies Burned in Pashupati Pyre in last six months: 2075/01/31:567, 2075/02/31:715, 2075/03/32: 574, 2075/04/31:824, 2075/05/31:669, 2075/05/12:261
  48. Ashish Ghimire is a Project Manager under Ministry of Urban Development, Government of Nepal at High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of the Bagmati Civilization, Panchakanya Marga, and Kathmandu 44600.
  49. Eric de Place & David Kershner, ‘How Coal Affects Water Quality: State of The Science’, 20 March 2013, Satellite Institute available at https://www.sightline.org/2013/03/20/how-unburnt-coal-affects-water-thes-tate of-the-science/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  50. Peter M. Chapman, James Downie, Allan Maynard et al., ‘Coal and deodorizer residues in marine sediments contaminants or pollutants?’, vol. 15, no. 5,Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1996, pp. 638–642.
  51. C. Achten & T. Hofmann, ‘Native polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in coals - A hardly recognized source of environmental contamination’, vol. 407, no. 8, Science of The Total Environment, pp. 2461-2473.
  52. Ryan Johnson & R.M. Bustin, ‘Coal dust dispersal around a marine coal terminal (1977–1999), British Columbia: The fate of coal dust in the marine environment’, vol. 68, no. 1-2, International Journal of Coal Geology, 2006, pp. 57-69.
  53. Prakash Mani Sharma on behalf of Pro-public v. His Majesty's Government Council of Ministers and others, NKP, 2056.
  54. Ibid.
  55. Bharat Mani Gautam v. His Majesty's Government, Council of Ministers and others, NKP, 2056.
  56. Ibid.
  57. Santosh Kumar Mahot v. Council of Ministers. WN 3034, 2061.
  58. Ibid.
  59. The Government of Nepal Act, 1948(2004 B.S), see part II, art. 4.
  60. Ibid, preamble.
  61. The Interim Government of Nepal Act, 1951 (2007 B.S).
  62. Ibid, art. 12.
  63. The Constitution of the Kingdom of Nepal, 1959 (2015 B.S).
  64. Ibid, art. 5.
  65. The Constitution of Nepal, 1962 (2019 B.S).
  66. Ibid, art. 9.
  67. Constitution of Nepal (n 62), art. 15.
  68. The Constitution of the Kingdom of Nepal, 1990 (2047 B.S)
  69. Ibid, art. 24.
  70. The Interim Constitution of Nepal, 2007 (2063 B.S.), art. 16.
  71. The Constitution of Nepal, 2015 (2072 B.S.), art. 30.
  72. In which the Ministry of Urban Development High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of Bagmati Civilization (HPCIDBC) came up with the BAP as one of the major achievements of the collaboration with National Trust for Nature Conservation (NTNC).
  73. BAP covered the Bagmati river system from Shivpuri hill to Katuwal Daha. The total plan outlay for five years was approximately NRs. 15,000,000,000 (Fifteen Billion) to tackle the issues of decrease in water discharge and the degradation of river ecosystems. Also, narrowing and deepening of the waterway, degradation of catchment quality and water quality, eroding aesthetic and cultural values, riverside land use changes etc. were seen as some of the critical issues of the Bagmati river system.
  74. ‘273rd week of Bagmati clean-up drive marked’, The Himalayan Times, 05 August 2018 available at;https://thehimalayantimes.com/Kathmandu/273rd-week-of-bagmati-clean-up-drive-marked/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  75. Ashish Ghimire is a Project Manager under Ministry of Urban Development, Government of Nepal at High Powered Committee for Integrated Development of the Bagmati Civilization, Panchakanya Marga, and Kathmandu 44600.
  76. At every clean-up, on the low end, at least 10 metric tons of waste has been taken out of the river at different locations. In December of 2017, 37 metric tons of waste was collected from Bagmati River across the Kathmandu Valley, and just a month later, in January of 2018, 30 metric tons of waste were collected, which begs the question about the approach of the clean-up. Of course, major sewerage points have been diverted away from the river and throwing waste directly into the water body has been strictly regulated. However, a stroll near the banks of Bagmati and its rivulets at different points inside the valley shows plastic bags stuffed with household waste still floating in the body. To give a larger picture, at the beginning of 2017, 37 metric tons of waste was collected from the river. See ‘No reduction in plastic litter in Bagmati’, The Himalayan Times, 02 August 2017 available at https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/no-reduction-plastic-litter-bagmati/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  77. “Bagmati River gets polluted yet again; fish start dying’, The Himalayan Times, 13 January 2018 available at https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/bagmati-clean-up-campaign-river-gets-polluted-yet-again/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  78. ‘Over 37 metric tons of garbage collected in Valley’, The Himalayan Times, 23 December 2017 available at https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/over-37-metric-tonnes-of-garbage-collected-in-valley/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  79. ‘37 metric tons of garbage managed from major rivers in the valley’, The Himalayan Times, 22 April 2017 available at https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/37-metric-tons-garbage-managed-major-riverskathmandu valley/, accessed on 30 September 2018.
  80. P. K. Goel, Water Pollution: Causes, Effects, and Control, New Age International, 2006.